Log in

No account? Create an account
Doctor Who? More Like Doctor Shoo! *Turns into Half a Camel* - The Book of the Celestial Cow

> Recent Entries
> Archive
> Friends
> Profile
> My Website

July 8th, 2005

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
06:23 pm - Doctor Who? More Like Doctor Shoo! *Turns into Half a Camel*
So I just finished the new Doctor Who. OMG SO GOOD. You could even say it was, you know, fantastic.

For the first few episodes, I thought it was entertaining fluff. The Doctor and Rose go around traveling through time and space and having wacky adventures. Yippee. Every now and then they would quite literally save the world, huh? But was there any overarching story? Would there be some sort of character development? Come on, missus!

After nearly half the season (though remember, the season's only thirteen episodes), finally I saw that the show had some meat in it. And then it started gobsmacking me with the continuity and the impression that they had in fact planned out the entire season in advance because suddenly all the little things were becoming important, they were not forgotten, this was all one story about one world, simply split into episodes. Hell, this was a show where the title of an episode didn't make sense until five episodes later.

Oh, a bonus note: the Brits are way better at previews than we are. The previews give just enough to whet your appetite, and then when you watch the actual episode, you realize they didn't give much away at all. Not that they're misleading, but they don't feel as spoilerrific.

At first, I thought the Doctor was a little too wacky, but as the series progressed, he got more depth. We learned some of his history, what he does, why his life had made him who he is. And Christopher Eccleston plays all the facets of the character with such aplomb, from wacky to serious to terrified to everything in between, that you can see how these somewhat conflicting personalities can all exist in the same person.

For a while, Rose just seemed to be the girl accidentally causing trouble or getting into trouble so the Doctor could save her. But she, too, got some great character development, as she discovered the difference between life with the Doctor and her normal, humdrum life on Earth. She kind of functions as the audience surrogate. And Billie Piper also rocks the hizzouse.

It's silly, it's fun, it's entertaining, it's exciting, it's dramatic, it's clever, it's smart. It's excellently plotted. It's got soul. valancy makes the interesting comparison to Angel, in that it's a series about helping the helpless. It's more than that, though, because the Doctor, because he travels through time, knows what must be done, what must happen. It's also a series about Making the Hard Choices, and the Rose factor makes it a series about Ordinary People Doing Extraordinary Things. Add those to the bucket of Things Sunil Likes in His Television, people. Along with Identity Issues and Power Struggles. And Hot Chicks and Cleavage.

If you haven't checked this show out, do so immediately. If you have, why follow me into the spoilery portion of the post.

"Rose": WTF living plastic? It was fun, and the Doctor is rather wacky, and shut up, Mickey.

"The End of the World": I keep forgetting this episode even exists. Not that it's bad and I don't like it or anything. It was okay, and still a bit silly with the iPod joke, and I was still getting used to the tone of the series. The Doctor's "Oh, it would be you" was hilarious, and awww for his poor tree girlfriend.

"The Unquiet Dead": WTF Charles Dickens? Decent episode with good zombie action. And I liked the solution of turning up all the gas to draw out the Gelth.

"Aliens of London": Whoa, alien invasion! Fun! Except, weird. I thought the Slitheen's plan to fake an invasion in order to kill the alien experts was terribly clever, though I could have lived without all the fart jokes.

"World War Three": OMG they blew up 10 Downing Street! And aw, how cool is it that the idiot Mickey pushed the button? I love how the Doctor is totally fearless when he knows something someone else doesn't know (e.g. the giant monologue before he seals them off behind reinforced steel).

"Dalek": Ah, the episode that hooked me good. All I knew was that the Daleks were the big bad in the Whoniverse. The other thing I knew was that the Doctor laughed in the face of danger, and he didn't hide until it went away. So to see him utterly terrified of this silly robot-looking thing was fucking awesome. And then I loved that the Dalek lived up to the terror as it went around vaporizing people, stopping bullets à la Neo, and setting off the sprinkler system for a mass electrocution. I also loved the conflict between the Dalek and the Doctor: "You would make a good Dalek." OH SNAP. Then there's all this stuff about getting emotions from Rose's DNA and whatnot, but hey. It was still cool.

"The Long Game": Adam is a fuckwit. But I loved how pivotal he ended up being to the plot of this episode. Little things like Rose's giving him the TARDIS key and the Doctor giving him unlimited credits aren't just throwaway actions. I also loved the blatantly obvious social commentary. And like I said above, I can't think of another show where the title of a fucking episode doesn't make any damn sense for five freaking episodes. Honestly, I had been wanting to ask someone. I was like, "I don't get the title of 'The Long Game.'" And then the Doctor said it in "Bad Wolf" and it was like OMG.

"Father's Day": Finally, some time travel hijinks! I had been waiting for them to address the reason they couldn't just go back and fix their wacky adventures from ever happening. And the reason is...gargoyle dragons. Who, if time is altered, eat everyone and everything? That's a dumb system. That's not cleansing the wound, that's killing the patient! Well, maybe they just eat everyone on Earth. While it was a nice episode for Rose and her daddy awww, I was still left a bit disappointed by the hardcore not making sense. I expected a smarter, more tightly woven explanation of how time was affected and how to return things to normal. Instead, it's oh, everyone's alive again and doesn't remember anything. Also, the Rose paradox totally shouldn't have happened that quickly because she was only touching baby Rose's clothing; their skin hadn't even made contact. But I liked the car stuck in a time warp, and I liked that Rose's dad realized the proper solution himself. Though it would have been deliciously sick if Rose was forced to kill her dad. But I don't think it's that kind of show.

"The Empty Child": I really liked Nancy. She was rather pretty. And WHY ARE SMALL CHILDREN SO FUCKING CREEPY?! "Are you my mummy?" Eeeeeeeee. And ooh, Captain Jack, whom I didn't really like at first cause he was a bit full of himself and sort of an ass. He looks like Scott Wolf. This is a really good episode, nice and creepy and it also brings the zombie action! Except the zombies have gas masks for heads. And then OMG cliffhanger!! I wasn't expecting that.

"The Doctor Dances": Run away from the zombies! Oh no you're trapped! WTF teleporting? Bastard! But dude, his Sonic Whatchamawhozit is fucking awesome. Loved the Doctor's Sonic insecurity. And okay, seriously? The nanogene thing is fucking brilliant. Again, something that seems like a throwaway detail turns into a major plot point. And it actually makes sense. I love that the ambulance wasn't empty. I love that the nanogenes stupidly fixed the first lifeform they came across the only way they knew how. I love that they stupidly decided that was the prototype human and fixed everyone else exactly that way. I love that something so menacing, something so potentially destructive...was just some poor little machines trying to do the right fucking thing. I love that they recognized that Nancy was the mother and unless she fucked a gas mask, humans were probably supposed to be more like her. I love the Doctor's ecstatic joy: "Just this once, everybody lives!" See, damn, that almost made me cry just writing that. I love how resigned Jack is to blowing up, and I love that the Doctor and Rose save him. This episode rules.

"Boom Town": Holy continuity, Batman! The Slitheen! The Cardiff rift! It's a decent enough episode, but I think I was too itching to get to "Bad Wolf." I enjoyed the little date, and the Doctor's systematic defense of each one of her attacks. Though I really just wanted her to shut up with the attempted guilt trip. Dude, you tried to destroy the Earth. You get no sympathy. And you probably did something really bad on your home planet too, or they wouldn't want your head. But I liked the Buffy-esque "OMG 'Bad Wolf' is everywhere!!...Oh, it's probably just a coincidence." Also, Rose really needs to quit fucking with Mickey's head, and Mickey needs to move on, stat. It was pretty clear that they were good together, and nothing more. They weren't madly in love or anything. Not that that gives Rose an excuse to treat Mickey like crap or Mickey to throw in a self-pitying whinge every other sentence. Shut up, you two. Just be friends and be done with it. Also, I'm not entirely sure I understood all the weird tripping the rift mumbo jumbo. The heart of the TARDIS thing was...odd, as well.

"Bad Wolf": Ha, reality TV satire now, eh? And ooh, it's in Satellite Five! Anne-droid. Hee. And whoa, "Bad Wolf" was in more places than I'd even noticed. So cool! It's kind of like the Numbers appearing everywhere on Lost, except it actually means something. It's all good fun for a while, and then OMG they killed Rose. And you know, I honestly thought maybe they did. I knew Christopher Eccleston wasn't coming back, so I thought, huh, maybe she isn't either. Damn. Then, whee, Daleks! And how fucking cool is the Doctor? How fucking awesome is his "I don't know what the fuck I'm doing, which is why you'd better be scared as hell, motherfuckers!" speech? I couldn't even wait until dinner to see the thrilling conclusion.

"The Parting of the Ways": Well. Creating Daleks out of humans? Freaky. The Daleks worshipping the Emperor? Freaky. The Daleks killing basically every expendable human we'd come to know? Damn. I don't know if it happened before this, but I definitely liked Jack after this episode. God, there are way too many television characters named Jack. I loved the scene where Rose realizes she can't go back to this ordinary life of fish and chips, and it's not because she's seen too much, it's because she's done too much. She's discovered the ability to change things, to make a difference, to fight. And aww, Mickey and her mum help her out. I also love, again, that the Daleks make the Doctor question his motives. Can he do it, can he kill them all? How does that make him different from them? And then, whoa, TARDIS-Rose. Just whoa. Intellectually, maybe it's an asspull, but it's such a glorious asspull, and the show is behind that asspull 110%, that it works. I'm still not sure I understand the actual significance of "Bad Wolf," that it really did anything for Rose to scatter those words across her own timestream. Except, wait, I think I get it. It's because she realizes the words are following her, and not the Doctor. Nifty. I almost thought she'd go mad with power à la Evil Willow, but luckily, no. At least she brought Jack back to life first. But no more Christopher Eccleston waaaaaah. I don't know how he compared to the other Doctors, but I think he rocked. And I don't know how they dealt with multiple Doctors before, because I thought they were actually different people, but this looks like David Tennant wil be trying to play Christopher Eccleston's character, which will be weird. He'd better not suck.

And now you get to hear the Dalek Song.

Now, to see if I can mainline Battlestar Galactica before the season premiere.
Current Mood: hungryhungry
Current Music: Of Montreal - Upon Settling on the Frozen Island, Lecithin Presents Claude and Coquelicot with His A

(36 memoirs | Describe me as "inscrutable")


[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 10:27 pm (UTC)
I cried so much.

I cried whole worlds.

And no, he'll be a new Doctor, Regeneration always hits with a little daffy bemusement.
Date:July 8th, 2005 10:35 pm (UTC)
Mmm. Brain-eating sci-fi. It's totally sonic!
[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 10:44 pm (UTC)
I finally get your icon, buttons. It was a nice moment.
[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 11:03 pm (UTC)
Yay on the Whoing. Jack crept up on me too. I was convinced I hated him at the end of TEC, and then all of a sudden I was his best friend. Also the Rose/Mickey thing was eye-rolling but completely believable.

Tennant will be great.
[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 11:17 pm (UTC)

Now you;ve seen it all, you can watch The Dalek Song Without being spoiled for the finale! Yay! *veg*
[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 11:26 pm (UTC)
And oh yesh the "Bad Wolf "references were many! Almost every episode, I think...

Did you spot in in german written down the side of the bomb in The Doctor Dances? In Father's Day as grafitti on the wall when Rose and The Doctor go back again?

And that the newsreader in World War Three was called "Mal Loup" (french)? Too cool.
[User Picture]
Date:July 8th, 2005 11:41 pm (UTC)
So awesome.

You just reminded me how awesome and wonderful and sad it all was and how I cried and cried until I remembered that I don't cry like a little bitch so I stopped, but still wanted to.

Soooooo awesome.

it's kind of like the Numbers appearing everywhere on Lost, except it actually means something.


It's funny cuz it's true.
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 12:36 am (UTC)
Because it's raining and I'm tired & grumpy, I will take this opportunity to bitch a little about the new series:

I never warmed to Captain Jack, especially not after TPOTW. He's supposed to be this swashbuckling '40s serial action hero type, but Barrowman doesn't quite pull it off for me. Like, there's that scene around 34:34 where he's firing his little uzi at the Daleks and yelling "Doctor, you've got twenty seconds maximum!", and he looks like some little kid squirting a water gun at his friends. Then there's his big speech where he delivers lines like, "If you hear us DYING, then tell me that the Daleks aren't real", with all the authority of a snotty teenager. I just don't find him very cool, unlike say, Harrison Ford as Han Solo, who had this certain rugged charm.

I think I would've preferred having Adam along a little bit longer. That scene with his mother at the end of "The Long Game" was hilarious, though. Simon Pegg did a nice job in that episode, too.

I really loathe Murray Gold's scoring. Someone on OG described it as "tell the Sun readers what emotions to feel" cheese, which is spot on. There are times, such as in "Father's Day", where what's happening on the screen is moving enough, without having to hear Gold hammering it into our heads with his treacly, twinkly pianos. I wish someone like Rob Kral would head across the pond to work on this show.

I haven't even gotten to my main pet peeves yet, but this is enough complaining for one post. I actually do like the show, though.

As for the multiple Doctors, they're all the same person, but their physical body and personality changes with each regeneration.
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 12:45 am (UTC)
Eccleston & Piper are both great throughout the season, but the tone of the show ended up a bit too...well, I won't spoil it for you.

Time to finish your thought. :-}

I can kind of see your criticisms of Jack, but I guess I just don't see him as a swashbuckling '40s serial action hero type. I just see him as...who he is.

I don't think I really noticed the music, for better or for worse. Except the theme. I liked the theme.
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 05:32 am (UTC)
wait, dr. who has a plot?
I've been reading Dr. Who and the Doomsday Machine while in the water closet and I must say it's awesome.
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 05:38 am (UTC)
Oh, I forgot the most important question- what's the scarf like?
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 12:35 pm (UTC)
...what scarf?
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 06:44 am (UTC)
I almost thought she'd go mad with power à la Evil Willow, but luckily, no.

That whole thing put me much more in mind of Dark Phoenix, but, yeah. I was hoping for scary-power!Rose to hang out for a bit, but oh well.
[User Picture]
Date:July 9th, 2005 12:36 pm (UTC)
Oh, you're right, Dark Phoenix is probably a more apt comparison.
Date:July 9th, 2005 11:06 am (UTC)
erm, dalek song by THE Partyman? As in Bronzer Partyman?
Glad you liked teh cool english series. See, there are good things to come out of Salford and Cardiff.
[User Picture]
Date:July 10th, 2005 05:55 am (UTC)
I don't have much to add, but the scorpion-spectre-time-rift-eating flappy things in Father's Day really freaked me out. And I'm jaded.
Date:July 11th, 2005 12:30 pm (UTC)
Hi there--

I found a link to your LJ from OpenDiary, and because I like your Opendiary I followed it and friended you.
Date:July 13th, 2005 01:18 am (UTC)
Battlestar Galactica sounds a lot like the show, in the part about Daleks and Cylons. No?

I want to see Dr. Who so bad, but no fast internet connection leaves me in the dust. Do you know if there are caps yet? Cause I know my friend is looking for them.
[User Picture]
Date:July 13th, 2005 01:24 am (UTC)
I've only seen the BSG mini, but I don't think the Daleks and the Cylons have a whole lot in common so far.

I hope you find some way to see the show, it's so damn good. As for caps, check dwicons and _jems_.
Date:July 15th, 2005 05:49 pm (UTC)
Acccch. Best. Segue. Into. A new season. Ever.

I will IM with you now and chat.

> Go to Top